Problem 11.93

a) Since the forces are to be applied successively, I'll start by computing the deflection due to the force P on the right. Taking P acting at E (force 1 at position1, no force at D), and using Appendix D, case 5,

The subscript "11" refers to position1 and force 1. The deflection at D (position 2) because of this single force P acting at E (P1) is:

Now suppose P is applied at D (force 2, position 2) - without the other force P at E:

The subscripts mean: "22 = position 2, force 2." Of course, P1 and P2 are simply P. Without going through the same algebra, it should be clear from the symmetry that

I'll drop the minus signs since all of
the deflections are down. If P1 is applied first, load-displacement
diagrams can be drawn (see also Fig. 11.40 on page 710):
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
Explanation -- P1 is applied
first (it could have just as well have been the other way around). As it
is applied slowly (and increased to its maximum value), the displacement
y1 also increases until the curve reaches the point C'1
and the plot is a straight line of slope
,
or as the text would write (Figure 11.39 and since the authors begin with
P1), P1/x11. Now we apply P2
at D, slowly increasing its magnitude until it has reached the value of
P, during which we get the triangle in the second plot on the right. But
at the same time, P1 (plot on the left) does work, since it
moves through an additional displacement from C'1 to C1.
But its work is represented by a rectangle, since P1 is constant
while P2 is slowly increasing.
Now I can use the areas under the graphs to compute the energies:

To see how Castigliano's Theorem is used to find deflections, please look at this example.
b) To use the method of §11.4, I need the moment as a function of x. Each reaction force is equal to P, by symmetry.